My 24 hours at Little Green Footballs (LGF)


Wow, what a ride! As the title of this post indicates, I've just spent 24 hours being involved with of one of the most diverse and in-depth group conversations about Islam, Iraq, the War on Terror, and preemptive war that I've ever been a participant in (who'd thunk).

For one brief moment in time the screaming stopped (well, mostly), and what was really on people's minds and in their hearts came out. Concerns and anxieties on all sides were clearly expressed and addressed. There were things I disagreed with most vehemently, and there were even moments of perceivable, if not complete, consensus on a number of positions and concerns. Bottom-line for me is that I now have less cynicism about the people on the other side of the aisle. Most of their positions seem to come from genuine concerns about issues that we all think about. It's just their reactions to things, I'm finding, are what is different than mine.

This is not some "feel-good" slide into moral relativity, either. It's my conviction that some of the people I talked to had ideas that would make them, their family and friends, and the whole world a much less-nice place to live. But now I understand that they believe what they believe, too - really, really believe it. It's not a sham, not a scam, the Bush administration did not fool them into being scared (which is not to say the Bush administration doesn't try). They're not slobering rednecks or heathens, and they're not all just making it up as a diversion to keep their 401K rolling, either.

Go check out this thread at LGF. Things get going 4 comments down with the help of a comment from a very provocative author (me), but from that point on things take on a life of their own and the quality of the discussion goes way up. (the LGF post itself is somewhat incidental to this story, by the way)

Update: The original link I left on the LGF post is broken because it went to our old site. Here is an updated link.

They're still extremists and racists. What's your point?

Not yet rated.

I object to your question on the grounds that it is thought-provoking and relevant...Ok, seriously it's a good question.

First, if you read my comments about the LGF'ers views, I hope that I made my total and complete disagreement with them abundantly clear. I'm personally doing everything I can to make sure that we don't get 4 more years of the kind of leadership they want. With that disclaimer out of the way...

Where my experience with the folks at LGF ended up is best summed up by this commenter named "Grandma". She put herself out there, against her own fears and the catcalls from some of the more hostile LGF'ers. This was my reply back to her:
"I can't take anything away from you guys. You're making choices. That is better than just floating along aimlessly, almost any day. I think think there's some undeniable amount of cynicism behind you're stated feelings and positions, but you seem to be admitting that too, so what the heck. I will remind you all that I did advocate bombing al quaeda, "back to the stone age" at one point though, so I don't know if that qualifies me as a iron-clad pacifist. Don't know what else to say, but instead of "pontificating" anymore I'm joining in on Kumbayah for a while..."
The response above came from knowing that it was either a) say what I did say, or b) just flame, ridicule, and frankly live up to "Grandma's" fears that I was a "troll". Given her honest expression of her thoughts and beliefs I think anything less than my reply above would have just added to the noise and animosity of the world.

Thanks for the chance to clarify. I leave you with this:
Do not fancy you can stand aside from the bad man or the foolish man. They are yourself, though in a less degree than your friend or (teacher). But if you allow the idea of separateness from any evil thing or person to grow up within you, by so doing you create Karma, which will bind you to that thing or person till your soul recognizes that it cannot be isolated. Remember that the sin and shame of the world are your sin and shame; for you are a part of it; your Karma is inextricably interwoven with the great Karma. And before you can attain knowledge you must have passed through all places, foul and clean alike. Therefore, remember that the soiled garment you shrink from touching may have been yours yesterday, may be yours tomorrow. And if you turn with horror from it, when it is flung upon your shoulders, it will cling the more closely to you. The self-righteous man makes for himself a bed of mire. Abstain because it is right to abstain -- not that yourself shall be kept clean. - Light on the Path
Translated into an example: Even when Abraham had set his mind to kill Issac, he did not abandon his love of his son (fighting someone and loving them at the same time not being mutually exclusive).
Not yet rated.

Wow.... you're leading me into Kool Aid Kuntry for my 4th visit to LGF today....scary.

LGF is most definitely not a gruop who have been tricked by Bush. They are wingnuts who believe fiercely in their extreme right wing ideology to the point of religious fervor.

Wish me luck.... I'm goin in.

Not yet rated.

This post on the LGF thread sums it all up in my opinion.

"If I were to die horribly in a terrorist attack tomorrow, maybe the obituary in the morning papers would label me an ’Äúinnocent’Äù old lady. But I am not."

I'm amazed you were actually able to get a semi-civil discussion out of a couple of people. That's truly a rarity on LGF.

Not yet rated.

Thanks for your comments Nate. How in the heck did you end up on LGF 4 times in one day?!There are the die hard flame monkeys on LGf, but if you can ignore them a couple folks will usually pop up on the radar of reasonability. I think if I would have taken the bait from even one of the flame monkeys I would have been toast...

Not yet rated.

I can't believe you wouldn't rather have these creepy crawlers just "floating along aimlessly" rather than "making choices" to enable the Neo-cons to fuck up the world and send thousands to their inglorious deaths. What the hell are you thinking, man??

Not yet rated.

Well, I can partially see/share in your dismay.

Delmundo,

A smaller part of me would definitely rather have them "just floating along" than organizing and advocating policies that are arguably a total-disaster for our country and our world.

Another part of me:

  • realizes that what the "smaller part of me" wishes is irrelevant. They have their freewill and it isn't going anywhere whether I want it to or not. An aside - the desire to control someone's freewill is how totalitarian movements get started. (which I don't believe you are advocating, but still that is how they get started)
  • believes that at times people-in-general may only learn through making wrong choices (yes, it would be very, very nice if the "wrong choices" didn't have to be so aggregious)
  • realized the conversation at LGF seemed to be getting ready to take one of two directions - 1) myself and the LGF'ers tell each other to go "screw ourselves" (which seemed like an unproductive choice at best), or 2) we end the dialog as amiciably as possible, while still leaving it open for future discussions and the whole exchange is recorded for posterity so folks like yourself can judge the larger movements at play...
  • -----

Not yet rated.

Did you register with the site?

If so, check if you're banned.

You probably are.

Not yet rated.

Hi hp,

I've not been banned, nor would I hope that I'd do anything to deserve it, OR have anyone ban me if I didn't deserve it. Charles seems to be willing to let things go as long as they don't feel like you're intentionally gaming them. VodkaPundit on the other hand...

Have you had a different experience?

Not yet rated.

LGF

I think you missed the most important moral distinctions here.

The thread you participated in on LGF was about Palestinian Jihad's deliberately killing children. If those people continue to get their way, the violence will never stop. Innocents will be slaughtered forever because that is their direct intent.

Those pictures, (for the sake of argument I'll assume they are genuine - though Al Jazeera is not a reliable source), are the one time cost of delivering Iraq from under the boot of Saddam's thugs. If the people who harmed those children have their way, there will be no more violence in the Middle East, and certainly no more mass graves filled with Kurdish women and children.

I can only assume you ignore that most salient fact - that of ongoing violence because ongoing eternal violence doesn't bother you at all. It's not important enough for you to even notice.

I'm sure you feel pure as blown snow, though. Congratulations, you waded into the worst of human crimes, understood none of it, wagged your finger at the wrong party, and feel pure. So at least you got something out of all this suffering even if no one else did.

Not yet rated.

Lion's Gate Films?

What's someone from Lion's Gate Films doing on this comment stream? I saw the logo (LGF) and just had to find out. Gosh, and here I thought we weren't important enough for Lion's Gate Films to get their attention. And to think we even got one of their morality police, lecturing us on how we feel, and what we're getting out of suffering. Gee Mister. If I pray good enough, and promise to be waving the flag for Lion's Gate Films, do I get to play a part in your next religious flick? Oh where have you been all these months, oh awaited one? I promise I'm pure enough, even if the others aren't.

Not yet rated.

I comment fairly regularly on

I comment fairly regularly on LGF, don't always find agreement, naturally, but have found it is a strong resource and a serious, no-nonsense challenge to jihadis and hard-left extremists (please don't read that as an attack on the centre-left).

I'm gratified to read that you checked it out with a good attitude and came away with understanding. That's all anyone can ask, and I'm sure readers would be happy to have your input more often.

Not yet rated.

"I comment fairly regularly

"I comment fairly regularly on LGF, don't always find agreement, naturally, but have found it is a strong resource and a serious, no-nonsense challenge to jihadis and hard-left extremists (please don't read that as an attack on the centre-left)."

A "strong resource"?

Sure, for anyone who can't debunk half of the garbage posted there upon reading it (i.e.: people who have no solid background knowledge of the Middle East or Islam). Aside from that, the site runs stories that later turn out to be bogus (ex.: the N.J. Copt stabbings, among other incidents).

Not yet rated.

Yeah, when I originally posted this...

...it was 2004 just before the election and I was in that, 'well there's been a whole bunch of people who have screwed up big time, and maybe they'll admit/do something about it mindset'. I was hopeful in other words.

Well, as we've all witness the years (slowly) pass since then, it's been quite obvious that the LGF community as a whole have deserved their presently soiled reputation. I would not write the same article as I did above, today.

Maybe it was a 'feel good slide' after all. All in all I feel this post one of my more egregious miscalculations/misrepresentations that I've made while blogging.

Not yet rated.

Stick to the front page,

Stick to the front page, take it with a grain of salt, and it's a useful resource.

Venture into the comments, and you'll be in a world of hurt.

Kind of like Kos.

Not yet rated.
Powered by Bloggyland